Older drivers - Compulsory tests for senior citizens at the wheel? Not with Transport Minister Wissing
Federal Transport Minister Volker Wissing (FDP) has once again rejected stricter regulations for older drivers. "A mandatory health check-up from a certain age is out of the question for us in Germany," said Wissing in Brussels on Monday. At their meeting, the EU transport ministers agreed on a compromise according to which additional health tests would be possible in principle, but the decision would be up to the member states.
In Germany, stricter rules for older people would therefore probably be off the table. Compulsory medical examinations are "not proportionate", emphasized Wissing. In addition to Germany, Austria and Belgium, among others, had also campaigned against such a regulation.
EU states position themselves in the dispute over new driving license rules
According to the compromise, the member states should either require driving license holders to undergo a medical fitness test or provide a self-declaration of their health. Drivers would have to present these when applying for a new license every 15 years. The EU Commission had also proposed that driving licenses for people aged 70 and over should only be valid for five years. This would require them to provide information about their health more frequently.
Transport Minister Wissing rejects these additional regulations. Self-disclosure offers no added value for road safety, he criticized. "I think this is superfluous bureaucracy," said Wissing in Brussels, adding that the authorities were already overloaded. Germany therefore did not agree to the compromise, but was outvoted.
The EU Parliament still has to determine its position on the proposed legislation. Member states and MEPs will then negotiate the final law. The driving license reform also aims to introduce accompanied driving from the age of 17 in all member states as well as a digital driving license valid throughout the EU.
Accident researcher contradicts Wissing
According to an accident researcher, Federal Transport Minister Wissing underestimates the danger posed by senior citizens at the wheel. Although older people are not involved in accidents more often on average in absolute terms, this is due to the fact that they drive significantly less, Siegfried Brockmann, head of accident research at the insurance companies, told the German Press Agency. According to Brockmann, in terms of driving performance, just as many people die in accidents involving people over 75 as in accidents involving the high-risk group of 18 to 21-year-olds.
Brockmann proposes mandatory rides for older people with professionals as a measure to improve road safety. These could then provide feedback on their driving behavior, but without the possibility of taking people's driving licenses away.
According to figures released by the Federal Statistical Office in Wiesbaden on Monday, older drivers are more often at fault than younger drivers when they are involved in accidents resulting in personal injury. According to the statistics, people over 65 were the main culprits in more than two thirds of these cases last year (69 percent).
Read also:
- Despite the EU commission proposing shorter license validity for those aged 70 and above, requiring more frequent health declarations, Volker Wissing, the German Federal Transport Minister (FDP), rejects these additional regulations, calling it superfluous bureaucracy in Brussels.
- Germany, along with Austria and Belgium, opposes the implementation of compulsory medical examinations for older drivers, as suggested by the EU, arguing that stricter rules are not proportionate and would likely not be implemented in their country.
- Volker Wissing, the German Transport Minister, was criticized by accident researcher Siegfried Brockmann, who argues that Wissing underestimates the danger posed by senior citizens at the wheel. Brockmann proposes mandatory rides for older people with professionals to improve road safety, without the possibility of taking their driving licenses away.
Source: www.stern.de
