Tips for Challenging a Code Violation Notice
Each local government has established specific building regulations that property owners need to follow. These codes are designed to ensure that every property meets safety standards and does not pose a threat to the community. It's crucial for homeowners to maintain their properties in accordance with these regulations, as this is required when making significant renovations and repairs. When purchasing a property, it's important to check the permit history of the property to make sure it's in compliance.
Many routine maintenance tasks do not necessitate obtaining a permit. However, such work can sometimes be misinterpreted as a violation of building codes, leading to fines and other penalties. Code enforcement officials often conduct inspections and respond to complaints, which means that if someone reports a potential violation or an inspector notices something from the street, you may receive a notice.
Reasons for notices
The specific laws regarding code enforcement, inspections, and code violations differ from one area to another. Code enforcement officers typically cannot enter your private property without a court order. However, they can issue a violation notice if they see an apparent violation from the street.
Common issues include repairs on concrete steps, roof work, window repairs, and sidewalk maintenance. For instance, if you patch up cracks in your concrete steps or apply a protective coating, an officer or neighbor could mistakenly assume you're doing masonry work without a permit. Similarly, any roof work, window repairs, or sidewalk maintenance could lead to a false violation notice.
Taking legal action
Despite these challenges, suing a code enforcement officer for maliciously enforcing codes is unlikely to be successful. Most government employees enjoy some form of legal protection, known as qualified immunity, which shields them from legal action. While you could potentially sue the city or county, proving a conspiracy to target your home with code violations would be difficult.
Rather than resorting to litigation, consider following the recommended steps below to address the problem.
Steps to take
If you believe you've received a false code violation notice, here's what you should do:
- Gather evidence: Before responding to the notice, gather all the relevant documents proving that your project was code-compliant. Be prepared to present receipts for materials, detailed descriptions of the work performed, and any before-and-after photos or videos.
- Understand the code: Research the relevant building code to be able to discuss it intelligently. Begin with your state's building codes; your local government may have more stringent regulations. Remember that you won't need to become an expert, but understanding the violation you're accused of will help you make your case.
- Get in touch with the relevant department: Use the contact information provided in the notice to get in touch with the appropriate government department. Submit your evidence and explain the purpose and scope of the work, why it didn't require a permit (or that you did pull one), and any other pertinent information.
If you can, call to follow up your written correspondence. However, avoid being aggressive or confrontational.
- Apply for retroactive permits: If it turns out that you should have obtained a permit for your project, consulting a contractor or engineer might help you understand the requirements for a retroactive permit. This will often involve adjustments to the work or paying a small fee but usually won't require tearing everything apart and starting from scratch.
If you genuinely didn't violate any building codes, this process should clear up the issue. In some cases, the enforcement office might dismiss the violation even if your work was technically non-compliant.
Not every place gives you the chance to get a permit after the fact, so don't think you can do the work and then say sorry afterwards.
If you can't fix the issue with a letter explaining everything or taking some other action, then there's a good chance a hearing will be set up for your situation. (Again, the specifics of this will differ depending on where you live - here's how it goes in King County, Washington as an example, you'll have to look into the process in your region.) In most cases, this is just what it sounds like - you get to present your case, and a ruling will be made about the possible infraction. You're normally allowed to have a lawyer if you want one, but it's not necessary.
Once the hearing is done, a final verdict will be made on the violation. You could try to appeal it, but at that point paying a small fine and letting it go might be the better choice.
Read also:
- If you suspect that your home has been unfairly penalized due to a misinterpreted building code violation related to routine maintenance tasks, such as fixing cracks in concrete steps or applying a protective coating on roof work, it's essential to gather evidence, understand the relevant building codes, and communicate with the respective government department, providing them with documentation and a detailed explanation of your project.
- During a code enforcement hearing, it's crucial to present a clear and convincing case that your home improvements were code-compliant or that obtaining a retroactive permit would be a viable solution for addressing any violations identified in the original notice. Being prepared, understanding the relevant building codes, and maintaining open communication with the enforcing agency can help you navigate the challenging process of challenging a building code enforcement notice related to your home.
