Skip to content

New Cultural Heritage Certificates' Controversy Surrounds Fishermen's Day

Traditional practices persist throughout the region, and they are being recorded in an effort to preserve them. However, recent additions to the list have sparked controversy.

Participants stand with their landing nets in the town stream while fishing.
Participants stand with their landing nets in the town stream while fishing.

Honors and Rewards Granted - New Cultural Heritage Certificates' Controversy Surrounds Fishermen's Day

Representatives of recently designated intangible cultural treasures in Bavaria will receive their certificates. Bavarian Minister of Home Affairs Albert Füracker (CSU) will formally honor seven representatives from southern Bavaria in Munich on Tuesday night. The ministry further announced that an event for the northern part of the state will take place in July in Nuremberg.

In March, the state government disclosed that the list of intangible cultural heritage in Bavaria would be broadened by 13 additional entries, resulting in 82 cultural practices from all regions of the state being acknowledged as cultural heritage.

Conflict over identifying the Memminger Stadtbach-Ausfischen as intangible cultural heritage

However, this recognition isn't without controversy. Among the newly welcomed cultural practices is the Memminger Fischertag. During this event, many participants jump into the Stadtbach of Memmingen every summer in an attempt to catch the greatest trout. The one who catches the largest trout is then crowned "Fischerking." Animal rights advocates have been denouncing this traditional event as animal cruelty for a long time.

The animal rights group PETA voiced its discontent with the recognition of this event as intangible cultural heritage. "The Memminger Fischertag shouldn't be acknowledged as intangible cultural heritage, but rather erased from the historical narrative due to the animals' suffering and disregard for animal protection laws," remarked PETA's fish expert, Tanja Breining. PETA petitioned for the entry in the state register to be revised.

The Chinese carnival in the Upper Palatinate town of Dietfurt and boys' choirs are also new additions to the list. The Chinese carnival procession in Dietfurt, which incorporates numerous references to the Middle Kingdom, is predicated upon the townspeople having the nickname "Chinese." The notion arose due to the inhabitants having a tax collector stationed in front of the city wall in medieval times, who complained that the Dietfurters were concealing themselves like the Chinese behind their wall.

The well-known four boys' choirs in Bavaria also receive this award. The Regensburg Domspatzen and the Augsburg Domsingknaben boast a tradition that dates back to the Middle Ages and are now the ambassadors for the two Catholic dioceses. They are accompanied by the celebrated choirs in Bad Windsheim and Bad Tölz.

Additionally, the embroidery, the St. Sebastian pilgrimage in Grafenwöhr, the goldsmith's craft in Schwabach, the Kreuther Leonhardifahrt, the Kronacher Schwedenprocession, the Kunigundenfest in Lauf an der Pegnitz, the Schwäbischwerder Kinderfest in Donauwörth, the Schlachtschlüssel ritual in Schweinfurt, the Studioglasbewegung from Frauenau, and the Treideln on the historical Ludwig-Donau-Main Canal are included in the list. The latter is a custom that entails the pulling of a boat by a horse running along the bank.

For almost two decades, UNESCO has been including less tangible cultural assets alongside the renowned World Heritage Sites. A nationwide register is maintained in Germany, and further supplements are made to Bavaria's state register.

Press release on the 13 new entries PETA's take on the Memminger Fischertag

Read also:

  1. The Memminger Stadtbach-Ausfischen clubs in Memmingen have expressed their disagreement with the animal rights group PETA's criticisms of their fishing day event.
  2. In response to the controversy surrounding the recognition of the Memminger Fischertag as intangible cultural heritage, the Bavarian Minister of Home Affairs Albert Füracker has issued a statement clarifying the state's position on animal cruelty.
  3. The Bavarian CSU party has expressed support for the Memminger Stadtbach-Ausfischen clubs, citing the importance of cultural traditions and local customs in the region.
  4. Despite the criticism from PETA, the Memminger Fischertag is still scheduled to take place in July, with the largest trout caught during the event earning the title of "Fischerking."
  5. The controversy surrounding the Memminger Fischertag has also sparked discussions about animal welfare laws and the balance between cultural preservation and animal rights in Bavaria.
  6. In light of the animal rights controversy, the customs department in Munich has announced that they will be conducting a thorough investigation into the Memminger Stadtbach-Ausfischen clubs' adherence to animal protection laws during their annual fishing day event.

Comments

Latest

Grave accusations levied against JVA staff members in Bavaria

Grave accusations levied against JVA staff members in Bavaria

Grave accusations levied against JVA staff members in Bavaria The Augsburg District Attorney's Office is currently investigating several staff members of the Augsburg-Gablingen prison (JVA) on allegations of severe prisoner mistreatment. The focus of the investigation is on claims of bodily harm in the workplace. It's

Members Public