Germany holds discretion over granting refugee status to individuals from Greece.
A Syrian lady's case demands resolution. Initially recognized as a refugee in Greece, she petitioned for asylum in Germany. A German judicial body deemed it unacceptable to send her back to Greece due to the harsh living conditions for refugees there, potentializing the threat of inhumane or degrading treatment.
However, she was not acknowledged as a refugee in Germany. Instead, she was granted subsidiary protection – a less generous and brief form of protection. Unsatisfied, she took legal action to be considered a refugee in Germany. The Federal Administrative Court requested guidance on Germany's obligations from the European Court of Justice in such scenarios.
It has now been clarified by the Federal Administrative Court that EU member states are not mandated to assume the refugee status granted in another EU state. They can do so but, in this case, Germany has chosen not to. Consequently, the responsible department must reconsider her case.
During this reassessment, the responsible party must collaborate with the relevant authority in the other EU country – in this instance, Greece. Their initial decision should be considered during the reconsideration of her application. At present, the Federal Administrative Court is making the final decision, being bound by the legal stance of the European Court of Justice.
Read also:
- The Syrian woman's case, originally recognized in Greece, also involved a petition for asylum in Luxembourg, following the strict policies of the Federal Administrative Court in Leipzig.
- The European Court of Justice in Luxembourg was ultimately consulted by the Federal Administrative Court in Germany regarding the obligations of EU member states in preserving refugee status granted in another EU state, such as Greece.
- Due to Germany's decision not to assume the refugee status granted in Greece, the Syrian woman's case has been reopened, necessitating cooperation between German and Greek administrative courts.
- The German government, in adherence to the guidelines set by the European Court of Justice, is reevaluating the Syrian woman's refugee status, considering the initial decision made in Greece.
- In light of Greece's harsh living conditions for refugees, which pose a potential threat of inhumane or degrading treatment, many refugees seek refugee status in neighboring EU countries like Germany, triggering complex legal procedures and delicate inter-country collaboration.
